Infinite Menus, Copyright 2006, OpenCube Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SEARCH:   
 An Evening with Ilene Chaiken at Brava, part 1: Interview with Ilene

By BetteAndTinaForever

Brava! for Women in the Arts is a committed to the artistic expression of women, people of color and youth. Their mission is to produce, present and cultivate live art, which celebrates works that explore the intersections of multiculturalism and feminism that ignite social change as well as build community.

In celebration of Women’s History month Brava held a contemporary discussion about women in art and media with Ilene Chaiken.

I went to this event with a purpose in mind and it was to ask Ilene about her take on season six and the interrogation tapes webisodes. I arrived to the theater a little earlier and was able to get a few minutes alone with Ilene to talk about some things that I thought the audience might not ask.

Here’s our short interview.

B&TF: Looking back at The L Word, what stories were you trying to tell and what was your favorite because obviously the show meant different things to different people?

IC: I was trying to tell all those stories. I was just trying to entertain people and make good television.

B&TF: What were you hoping to achieve beyond simple entertainment?

IC: Simple entertainment is what I was trying to achieve. I thought that the real achievement was to make a television show about lesbians and have it be truly entertaining and function like all popular entertainment.

B&TF: Why then begin and end season six with death of one of the characters?

IC: It was the story we decided to tell. We liked the story, we thought it was a good story, we thought it was fun.

B&TF: It was a good story, I agree but it brought a lot of negativity.

IC: We didn’t see it as negativity.

B&TF: Even when all the characters who were Jenny’s friends began to hate her for different reasons?

IC: That’s already happened and I can’t tell you how many fans had asked me over the years to do something violent to Jenny. That didn’t come from me.

B&TF: It’s true then when you say you read the boards and listen to what fans say?

IC: Absolutely. That was a story that grew largely out of fans’ sentiments.

B&TF: Well, I heard a lot of fans saying, “Oh, I wish Jenny would die” or “I wish so-and-so would be killed” but I always thought it was just a figure of speech because personally for me, even if I don’t like the character I wouldn’t wish them any harm.

IC: I loved the character and it is fiction and it’s a fictional confection. It wasn’t a violent death and it wasn’t a hard-core murder story. It was a piece of entertainment consistent with all the rest of the entertainment we did.

B&TF: Why did you leave it open with so many suspects but no solution?

IC: Maybe it’s because the story is not over yet or maybe it’s just because it was the way we chose to tell it. We didn’t think that the point was ‘Who killed Jenny?’ or ‘Whether someone killed Jenny’. It was the vehicle for saying many, many things that we wanted to say to wrap up the show. And it was also a metaphor. It was a metaphor for the bittersweet moment in which we had to say goodbye to this show and these characters. Jenny brought us into this world and Jenny brought us out of it.

B&TF: Some people are actually saying that the entire The L Word was written by Jenny because she’s the writer. It began with her coming out and ended with her dead…

IC: All these speculations are valid.

B&TF: Interesting…so if you will get the green light to make a movie what will you do? Will you pick up where the show ended?

IC: I’m not even remotely prepared to entertain that question.

B&TF: Okay. Now we have interrogation tapes coming out every Monday. Are they the edits from the interrogation scenes we saw in the finale or are they the separate scenes you shoot just for this purpose?

IC: I won’t talk about the process behind shooting it or when we shot it or what it was intended for but the one thing that I will talk about is that that was all scripted material and it was scripted in response to the things that fans wanted to know about these characters.

B&TF: I remember there was a thread on OurChart where people were asking what they wanted to know.

IC: Yes.

B&TF: Well, this is a bit of personal question for me. I’m a big Tina fan and I know we all were asking for Tina’s background forever and finally we got it and lots of people were really shocked when they saw it. Who came up with this story and was it actually a recent development or was it developed over the years?

IC: I’m very, very collaborative with the actors that I work with and it was partly scripted and partly work shopped.

B&TF: So you mean that Laurel Holloman had input in this scene?

IC: Yes, Laurel had input.

B&TF: When I was watching it I wasn’t shocked that it happened because obviously child abuse happens in families but the way she was talking about this, like for Tina it wasn’t an abuse but just a childhood experience…

IC: It was a childhood experience. In her mind it was a childhood experience. These experiences aren’t always experiences of abuse and I take sexual abuse very, very seriously. But there are also childhood encounters that one had that don’t necessarily fall into a category of abuse. I think the more important thing is that fans wanted to know more about Tina and about her life and now we know that she grew up in the South and that she had a father who was in politics and he was very right wing and her mother left him. We know many, many things about Tina that we never knew before.

B&TF: I know that right now we have two tapes out for Tina and Shane. Can you give me a little hint what’s coming with Bette’s tape because fans are nervous now.

IC (laughing): No, I’m not going to give you a hint. It’s coming.

B&TF: Well, I know but we don’t even know if it’s going to be the last one or…

IC: That’s not my decision but you should hopefully tune in and see it.

B&TF: Yes, of course, I wouldn’t miss it.

My five minutes were up because Ilene had to prepare for the event. When she was announced Ilene talked for over an hour before answering a few questions and my report about “An Evening with Ilene” is coming up next. I, too, hope that you will tune in to find out what else Ilene had to say about her career, the show and her plans for the future.

COMMENTS DISCLAIMERS

L-Word.com is not affiliated with Showtime Inc. and no connection is expressed or implied.

Comments:

 Leave Comment (pop up window)

2009-03-28, 15:53:32 PM
From: claricestarling
Comments: Hey, thanks B&TF ! I think it's very interesting to learn that Laurel had input in Tina's background story... I would have never thought that. Granted it must have been really really frustrating for her not to have her background story told on screen when every other character had one, but in the words of Bette, I'm "flabbergasted" that she had any input in that particular story. Anyway, thanks for sharing this with us BetteandTinaForever, you're a rockstar !



2009-03-28, 17:19:38 PM
From: heartofartemis
Comments: Gosh B&TF, IC's answers to your questions leave me incredulous! So she killed Jenney because of the fans and it is not negative--it is fun entertainment? Give me a break!



2009-03-28, 17:57:29 PM
From: sunkissed
Comments: Hi B&TF!!! =) .. Well, once again you asked all the right questions! IC saying that Laurel Holloman had input of the backstory scene doesn't surprise me. LuH has said many times she goes to the writers with questions and seeks clarity and I can only imagine she did so up to the end. IC's answer doesn't tell us what part of the scene was influenced by LuH so I reserve any judgment on the matter except to say LuH did a fantastic job acting the scene. The implication that Tina's "childhood encounter" did not fall into the category of abuse is the shocker... IC does realize she wrote Tina as 11 or 12 years old when the "encounter" began doesn't she? That bit of perspective from IC surprised and disappointed me.Thank you, B&TF! You are awesome!!!



2009-03-28, 18:53:54 PM
From: windrider
Comments: So Chaiken made a whole season of killing Jenny off and everyone hating on her in the process because that's what the fans wanted? Yeah, that's entertainment. But it's not great television. The great shows are headed by someone who is loyal to the characters, who ensures that everything a character does proceeds out of that person's fundamental nature. There was to be none of that in the L Word, as Chaiken threw away one character after another. I gave up in Season 3, after Dana was written out. I tried to go back in Season 4 but it just wasn't doing it for me any more. You could see the puppet strings moving the characters through their story arcs, and frankly, by that time, there just weren't enough characters left that I really cared about that hadn't been written out, bumped off, or compromised beyond all plausibility.So yes Chaiken succeeded in producing a successful show. I hope not to be subjected to another one.



2009-03-28, 20:52:00 PM
From: fergz1
Comments: I stopped watching the tapes after Tina and won't watch another one...thanks for the interview B&TF.



2009-03-29, 02:03:13 AM
From: radiogal1
Comments: Thanks for posting your interview with IC. I don't think I will ever be comfortable in knowing that so many L Word fans actually hated Jenny's character so much that they wanted her dead(gulp), or so IC claims. As a huge Jenny fan, that really disappoints me. All the characters on the show had their fair share of quirks. Anyway, it was a good interview and I'm still very glad to have read it. It's a shame IC couldn't give a more revealing answer as to whether or not she is even interested in making an L Word movie. Not even a "yes", "no", "maybe" or even an "I don't know" answer. Why so secretive Ilene?



2009-03-29, 04:14:33 AM
From: lightning
Comments: Am I missing something... which episode did Tina's childhood come up in?



2009-03-29, 06:06:05 AM
From: claricestarling
Comments: Lightning, it wasn't in the actual show, but in the interrogation tapes webisodes that are being put on line every monday at sho.com. Tina's interrogation tape was the first one, then we got Shane's, then Helena's...



2009-03-29, 23:01:43 PM
From: shana69
Comments: I want to know is the L



2009-03-29, 23:02:23 PM
From: shana69
Comments: I want to know if the l word will be coming back on



2009-03-30, 08:07:57 AM
From: Saggittarian
Comments: Thank you so much B&TForever. You did a great job on that interview. As usual Ilene is hedgey. Just like a politician. Can't wait to see Bette's interrogation tape.



2009-03-30, 21:29:49 PM
From: Chicki
Comments: Wow, well...I agree with Sunkissed, um..11 years old Eileen! Hello? If Tina is explaining to the POLICE that her first was her sister, then this wasn't simply an isolated moment of play and exploration that may have gone a little too far. This was consistent over a period of years. BTF you did a great job. I'm so glad I wasn't the one sitting there, because I would have totally backed her into a corner on that outrageous and ignorant explanation. She is obviously back pedaling BIG time after the backlash she received. Whether it was from those people who just "cannot" accept Tina's past as having included sexual abuse,or whether it's victims such as myself who are offended by her "after thought" and callousness in failing to take such a sensitive issue and give it the proper attention, time and respect...the fans were OUTRAGED by this. So no matter which side the fans divided, the end result was discontent with her. Of course she is going to now come up with an even lazier attempt to explain herself. *phew* I need a cannoli my Italian is up! I can say that I'm VERY pleased to learn that LuH had some involvement in the Interrogation. I never thought for a moment that she felt it was "against" her character's background, and I am so pleased with her performance during that scene which I am sure was quite difficult. Thanks again!



2009-04-01, 03:08:32 AM
From: t_daze
Comments: Aaah hun..thanks so much for finding out some answers to our million questions-whether I agree with what she said is a different conversation all together. For her comments on "light fun entertainment", I remember an interview with IC where she said that this was a serious show, with serious issues to ensure our community was being portrayed...so where does her latest thoughts come from? As sunkissed and Chick commented...how could IC so flippently say it was an encounter? Abuse is abuse...especially when the one is too young to actually register what is happening. You gotta ask yourself in that situation of an "encounter"...is it something you would like to "encounter" again at such a young age..obviously not, so for me...IC lost it there. I can't believe the actors had a say in their tapes..firstly, I dont think JB would constitute her "admition" pfffttt as something relevant to her character..and as for Tina...I strongly doubt Laurel would have been happy with that...after so many years of begging for a background...thats what she got...for me, it's a slap in the face, especially with her interviews after the season was shot. But B&TF....TAHNKS SOOOO MUCH...in a way, you rested my complete anger for IC...not to sure what its morphided into though...lol...You really did ask her great questions and the fact that you kept your cool...I bow down to you in grace;)



2009-04-01, 05:43:01 AM
From: Braz
Comments: "IC: I was trying to tell all those stories. I was just trying to entertain people and make good television." Ahahaha...And she didnt do none of them...



2009-04-01, 09:35:33 AM
From: Seahurst
Comments: Hey B&TF, fabulous job as always! I couldn't do an interview like that because I would get angry and then every thought would go out of my head, and we would just be standing there staring at each other! LOL Here is my version of Laurel having input into her backstory. "Are you freaking kidding me with this Ilene!? This backstory sucks!" And, now Ilene can say that Laurel had input. She had it, Ilene just ignored it!! LOL Thanks B&TF!!



2009-04-29, 23:49:20 PM
From: tulips4u
Comments: I guess I missed this when it first came out. I am very surprised that Laurel Holloman had input into Tina's backstory. I will reserve judgment on that until Laurel makes any comments about it herself. I have no idea who all these fans were that wanted Jenny killed?? I thought her character was often extremely irritating, but Jenny added a lot to the show. I can't imagine that anyone would really have wanted to see her dead. IC sounds very rational, but I think she writes from her dark side much of the time. You did great B&TF.



Home | About Us | Contact | Advertise on this site | Privacy All Rights Reserved © 2009